All’s well for Tidswell at R.U. Brown

Published: May 31, 2008
(Page 1 of 1)

Adelaide – May 4, 2008 – Brett Tidswell of Adelaide won the Gold Medal Piobaireachd event at the annual R.U. Brown   Piobaireachd Society of South Australia’s solo piping competitions at Scotch College. Overall, Jori Chisholm of Seattle gained the most prizes.

Gold Medal Piobaireachd
1st Brett Tidswell
2nd Jori Chisholm
3rd Yasuchiyo Hamilton, Queensland, Australia
4th Ross Campbell, Queensland, Australia
5th Peter Hewlett
Judge: Malcolm McRae

Open MSR
1st Matthew Supranowicz, Queensland, Australia
2nd Jori Chisholm
3rd Ian Lyons,
Judge: Sam Young

Open Hornpipe & Jig
1st Jori Chisholm
2nd Ian Lyons, Victoria, Australia
3rd Andrew Fuller, Adelaide
Judge: Nat Russell

Silver Medal Piobaireachd
1st Andrew Cameron
2nd Andrew Silver, Melbourne
3rd Richard Wilson
Judge: Donald Gannaway

VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0

All’s well for Tidswell at R.U. Brown

Published:
(Page 1 of 1)

Adelaide – May 4, 2008 – Brett Tidswell of Adelaide won the Gold Medal Piobaireachd event at the annual R.U. Brown Piobaireachd Society of South Australia’s solo piping competitions at Scotch College. Overall, Jori Chisholm (pictured) of Seattle gained the most prizes.Gold Medal Piobaireachd1st Brett Tidswell 2nd Jori Chisholm3rd Yasuchiyo Hamilton, Queensland, Australia4th Ross Campbell, Queensland, Australia5th Peter HewlettJudge: Malcolm McRaeOpen MSR1st Matthew Supranowicz, Queensland, Australia2nd Jori Chisholm3rd Ian Lyons, Judge: Sam YoungOpen Hornpipe & Jig1st Jori Chisholm2nd Ian Lyons, Victoria, Australia3rd Andrew Fuller, AdelaideJudge: Nat RussellSilver Medal Piobaireachd1st Andrew Cameron2nd Andrew Silver, Melbourne3rd Richard WilsonJudge: Donald Gannawayp|dWhat do you think? We always want to hear from our readers, so please use our comments system to provide your thoughts!Do you have competition results? Be sure to send them to pipes|drums. We can’t report what we don’t know about! Please remember to support the businesses that advertise and make the not-for-profit p|d possible.

VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0
  1. bktidswell@hotmail.com

    I think you will find that at some time or other probably half the field has had some form of lesson or assistance from the judge. The prize winners seem to do consistantly well each year with a variety of judges. 12 wins to Tidswell, 3 to Campbell, several places to Hewlett. Chisholm has an unquestionable pedigree. Suggest these comments are rediculous and not supported by fact, history or general opinion.

  2. Lawrie

    Here here! It annoys me to no end when someone (who obviously has an issue with the result) uses a vehicle such as this to vent a personal gripe and in the process harm a superb event that is well run and looks after overseas players both financially and with hospitality. Tidswell is a regular in the prizes and pulled out a gem on the day, Campbell likewise (as per usual)and Hewlett has placed most years he has entered. Hamilton played a blinder and Chisholm is a class act. Makes sense to me. It is reasonable to expect that in a region that is not exactly awash with world class Piobaireachd authorities, that a number of people have sought guidence over the years from someone who meets the criteria, and that those people would enter contests and possibly be judged by that same person. To suggest an ethical problem is to highlight one’s ignorance to ALL the facts. Sour grapes perhaps….

  3. Lawrie

    That is only a matter of opinion – to which you are entitled of course – however, unless you sat there all day and heard all the performances, I’d suggest it is not constructive to come on here (of all places) and detract from what was a magnificent event that is trying to gain the wider profile it thoroughly deserves. I am quite sure that the judge was hoping someone would give him enough reason to split that top cluster up. As a judge, I have been in a similar position myself, but it is far more ethical to call it as you see and hear it, as opposed to engineering a result to avoid raised eyebrows. In my opinion, no-one gave the judge a good enough reason to break-up that top 5.

  4. Lawrie

    It is a sign of the times when one person can come on here, vent a personal gripe before giving themselves a chance to calm down and think it all through, and kick start all of this. Now we have people name dropping about grade 1 bands. Do you think we might get back on course now, please…? Go practice your doublings! The RU Brown is a superb event.

  5. nunapb@hotmail.com

    What the heck are you talking about D Mac? . I have friends in strathclyde who would never say the rubbish that you have just said about having a decent gr 1 band out here for the first time in a while. mate, maybe you need to get out of adelaide a bit more and wake up and smell the roses.

NEW APP AVAILABLE
The new pipes|drums app offers the same publication with a streamlined experience. Get the latest news optimized for your smartphone.
Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play
THIS DAY IN HISTORY:
August 3, 1966Capt. John MacLellan plays to packed house, Moss Park Armoury, Toronto.
MOST RECENT POST
  • New rules
    Sun, 2 Aug 2015
    I’m a moderate fan of Real Time with Bill Maher, and really like his “New Rules” segment. Spending two days judging an assembly line of competitors at Maxville, there’s hardly time enough to think about anything else between perfo …
Read more »
UPCOMING EVENTS August 5, 2015CARLOWAY PIPING CHAMPIONSHIPS-ISLE OF LEWIS

August 5, 2015Isle Of Skye Highland GamesThe Lump, Skye

August 7, 2015Dornoch Highland GatheringThe Meadows Park, Dornoch

August 8, 2015Fergus Scottish Festival550 Belsyde Ave. East, Fergus, ON

August 8, 2015Atholl & Breadalbane Highland GatheringWades Park, Atholl & Breadalbane (Aberfeldy)

TIP OF THE DAY
If you play in a pipe band, and aren’t the Pipe-Major or Leading-Drummer, follow these four rules (in order): show up, learn the music, shut up, and play.
Colin MacLellan, Edinburgh