Eric MacNeill resigns as Oran Mor leading-drummer

Published: September 30, 2012
(Page 1 of 1)

Eric MacNeill has resigned as Leading-Drummer of the Grade 1 Oran Mor Pipe Band of Albany, New York. MacNeill cited “irreconcilable differences” as the reason.

MacNeill had been a member of the band since 1996 and the lead-tip of the band since 2000, playing under Pipe-Major Andrew Douglas since Douglas took over the top spot in 2008. Oran Mor’s biggest success in the grade to date was qualifying for the Grade 1 Final at the 2011 World Pipe Band Championships. The band failed to make the Final at this year’s event, finishing seventh in the qualifying round.

“Andrew [Douglas] and I have irreconcilable differences with reference to the future direction of the band,” MacNeill said in a statement to pipes|drums.

“After this year’s Scotland trip, and a disappointing drumming result, the Oran Mor leadership set out to brainstorm ways to re-energize the drum corps such that we could contend in the Worlds final in 2013,” Douglas said. “We all, including Eric, agreed that the corps had reached a place where something big would be required to reach the next level. Many ideas were discussed, and among these ideas was the suggestion of potentially bringing on someone else to lead the corps. Our conversations were always very candid, sincere, and inclusive. It was clearly communicated to Eric throughout these discussions that there was absolutely no intention of forcibly removing him from his position as lead tip, but it eventually became apparent that Eric felt it was appropriate that he leave the band. We are deeply saddened by Eric’s decision, but are confident that we will be able to move the band forward in a positive direction in the coming season.”

Oran Mor had an extended visit to Scotland in August of this year, and enjoyed a first in the MSR and a second in the Medley competition at the North Berwick Highland Games.

MacNeill said that he plans to play with the Simon Fraser University Pipe Band. It is not known who will be taking over as leading-drummer at Oran Mor.

MacNeill is the current President of the Eastern United States Pipe Band Association.

Stay tuned to pipes|drums for more on this story as information becomes available.

VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 5.0/5
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: +1
  1. mikeo

    Did not see this coming. Eric will be very difficult to replace. I thought he was doing a very good job and they were constantly improving. What a bummer!

  2. Voltron

    Yea total shock. I just watched the podcast on Dojo and thought all was good with Eric and Andrew. Will be hard to replace!

  3. herecomethedrums

    Has anyone ever thought of getting a TV series set up Divorce Court – Pipe Band Edition”??? Everyone is falling out this year!”

MOST RECENT POST
  • Forward
    Fri, 17 Oct 2014
    The 2015 World’s format is backwards. It’s hard to fault the organizers for having another go at the 2014 format: Friday only Grade 1 qualifying; Saturday is the Grade 1 Final and everything else. It’s an opportunity missed. But i …
Read more »
UPCOMING EVENTS October 25, 2014Central Virginia Celtic Festival & Highland GamesRichmond International Raceway, Richmond VA

October 31, 2014Tucson Celtic FestivalRillito Raceway Park, Tucson , AZ

November 8, 2014PPBSO AGM and GALABest Western Brant Park Inn, 19-Holiday Inn Drive, Brantford

November 15, 2014Angus Macdonald ChampionshipsLakeside, CA

November 21, 20142014 Balmoral ClassicPittsburgh, PA

TIP OF THE DAY
Learning the scores note-for-note is acceptable; however, learning how to adjust the scores to the pipe tune is the key to playing music.
Graham Kirkwood, L-D, Niagara Regional Police