MacKenzie Caledonian changes L-Ds mid-performance

Published: September 30, 2012
(Page 1 of 1)

The Grade 2 MacKenzie Caledonian Pipe Band of Dundee, Scotland, made what is thought to be a first for the piping and drumming world when the band officially changed leading-drummers in the middle of its medley competition performance at the last contest of the season at the Pitlochry Highland Games on September 9th.

The drum section made the move during the slow air when the band played up to Grade 1, and Barham Brummage transitioned duties to new lead-tip Calum Burns.

“It was suggested by the Pipe-Sergeant in a moment of madness that it would be a good idea to make the transition mid-way through the Grade 1 performance,” Brummage said. “An appropriate moment was identified in the slow air and the change was made ushering Calum Burns into his position as Leading-Drummer of the band. I would not imagine such a transition has been done before and certainly not so public. Not all changes are done with general disharmony.”

While drummers have at times had to take over the lead-tip position mid-performance due to illness or instrument malfunction, a permanent transition of duties mid-competition-performance has likely never occurred before.

The majority of leadership changes in pipe bands are made with some acrimony, and most recently the Grade 1 Peel Regional Police Pipe Band of Ontario dismissed Leading-Drummer Graham Brown, with most of the drum section following him in protest. Brown subsequently joined House of Edgar-Shotts & Dykehead. The band has reportedly already built a drum section of eight under new Leading-Drummer Graham Kirkwood.

VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 1.5/5
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0
  1. uilleannonlooker

    can’t see the problem in it, seems like a nice gesture, might not be for a major championship but at a minor games and if no rules are infringed, why not? they were just thinking outside the box inside the circle.

MOST RECENT POST
  • Easy prizes, or challenging fun?
    Sun, 19 Apr 2015
    Play easy and boring music well, or play harder and interesting stuff and have more fun? It’s an age-old quandary for lower grade pipers and pipe bands. Almost every judge would say (over and over again), play tunes that your … Co …
Read more »
UPCOMING EVENTS May 2, 2015Savannah Scottish Games & Highland GatheringBethesda Academy 9520 Ferguson Avenue Savannah GA

May 2, 2015The LivingstoneHamilton, Ontario

May 2, 2015Ogden Legion Indoor CompetitionCentennial High School 55 Sun Valley Boulevard S.E., Calgary, Alberta

May 9, 2015Kiwanis Amateur Piping/Drumming & Mini Band CompetitionLondon Central Secondary School, London, ON

May 9, 2015Bob Worrall RecitalThe London Club, 177 Queens Ave

TIP OF THE DAY
If you’re not enjoying it, don’t do it.
Andrew Berthoff, Toronto

FROM THE ARCHIVES