PPBSO reverses Glengarry DQ at Montreal

Published: September 30, 2009
(Page 1 of 1)
The Pipers & Pipe Band Society of Ontario has reversed a decision to disqualify the Grade 2 Glengarry Pipe Band at the Montreal Highland Games on August 2, 2009, acknowledging a misinterpretation of the society’s rules.
 
Glengarry had been disqualified on the day of the competition for not fielding two tenor drummers, citing a rule that had been enacted in 2006 requiring Grade 2 bands to compete with at least two tenors to meet minimum requirements. The rule, however, had been rescinded at the PPBSO’s annual general meeting in November 2008, returning minimum numbers in Grade 2 to six pipers, two snare drummers and a bass.
 
In a letter to the Glengarry Pipe Band Pipe-Major Colin Clansey, PPBSO President Bob Allen said, “Please accept my apology for disqualifying the band at Montreal. My interpretation of the rule pertaining to tenor drummers was wrong. Tenors are not required. Again . . . my apologies.”
 
Allen said that the wording of PPBSO Rule D.6.3 “leaves much to be desired and I have suggested that it be revised.”
 
Since the judges at the competition had nothing to do with the initial decision to disqualify Glengarry, they proceeded to adjudicate the band accordingly. With the disqualification rescinded, Glengarry officially finished fifth in the six-band competition, with a second and third in piping, sixth in drumming and fourth in ensemble.
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0

GET THE MOBILE APP!
The new pipes|drums app offers the same publication with a streamlined experience. Get the latest news optimized for your smartphone.
Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play
THIS DAY IN HISTORY:
October 17, 1974James McIntosh wins 1st ever Grant’s Piping Championship, Blair Atholl.
TOP STORIES
Articles from the last three months with the highest overall ratings by readers.
  1. Hundreds salute Reay Mackay
  2. Blair digital chanter promises to rock piping
  3. Forget not
  4. RISEN
  5. A message of thanks
MOST RECENT POST
  • Remember empathy
    Wed, 4 Oct 2017
    Why do many judges forget what it was like to be a competitor? This came up the other day in a conversation about judging, competing, and judges. The current flap by a vocal minority about the Solo Piping Judges Association … Cont …
Read more »
UPCOMING EVENTS October 21, 2017Labour Weekend Silver Chanter Solo CompetitionsChristchurch

November 4, 2017London CompetitionsKensington Conference & Events Centre, The Town Hall, Hornton Street London

November 5, 2017Bloomington Pipers’ Society November GatheringSt Thomas Lutheran Church, Bloomington, IN

November 10, 2017Silicon Valley Pipe & Drum WorkshopSaratoga, CA

December 3, 2017Bloomington Pipers’ Society December GatheringSt Thomas Lutheran Church, Bloomington, IN

TIP OF THE DAY
Play each two-bar-phrase in a jig like a strathspey – accent pattern Strong, Weak, Medium, Weak. It will transform your tune musically.
Colin MacLellan, Edinburgh