March 09, 2022

Eller, Senyk & Troy: the Canadian Big Three – Part 2

L-R: Hal Senyk, Ken Eller and Jamie Troy, Glasgow, 2019.

We continue our exclusive conversation with three of the greats of the pipe band game: Clan MacFarlane Pipe-Major Ken Eller, Triumph Street Pipe-Major Hal Senyk, and City of Victoria Pipe-Major Jamie Troy.

These masters of pipe band leadership helped to spearhead a tectonic shift, from a domain of near-exclusive competition success by UK bands, to a worldwide phenomenon, where international groups were consistently competing at the same level with the globe’s best, and realistically vying for a World Championship title.

Not to diminish the contributions of Grade 1 bands like Worcester Kiltie of Massachusetts, or City of Toronto, New Zealand’s Innes Tartan, Ontario’s Guelph and Macnish Distillery, or even Ireland’s St. Patrick’s Donaghmore, each of which made their marks.

But City of Victoria, Clan MacFarlane, and Triumph Street in the 1970s and early ’80s turned the heads and caught the ear of a world audience, bringing down perceptual barriers that seemed to prevent judges from agreeing that non-Scottish pipe bands are worthy of not simply a prize, but the prize.

More than any others, these bands paved the way over their two decades for the international success that we see today.

In Part 1, Eller, Senyk and Troy looked back at the conditions of the times, their respect for each other’s bands in a pre-internet era, and their consciousness, or lack of it, of doing something historically important.

Eller, Senyk & Troy: the Canadian Big Three – Part 1

In Part 2, the group delves into the bands that inspired them 40-50 years ago, the bands of today that might be a model to emulate, and, through the benefit of hindsight, what they might do differently today. They discuss the essential roles that lead-drummers John Fisher, John Kirkwood and Willie McErlean played for City of Victoria, Clan MacFarlane and Triumph Street, respectively.

It’s a fascinating and occasionally light-hearted dialogue with three of the world’s greatest contributors to the pipe band art.

Ken Eller was pipe-major of St. Catharines, Ontario-based Clan MacFarlane for more than 20 years. Beginning in the 1960s and continuing until the mid-1980s, Eller guided “The Clan” to a raft of North American Championship titles, creating a trademark

Ken Eller

and legendary big sound to rival anything on earth. Surrounded by a stalwart and committed group of players, including pipers like Bob MacCrimmon, Scott MacAulay, Peter MacKenzie, Ron Rollo, Dave Goodall, and drummers such as John Kirkwood, Bob Downs, Douglas Kirkwood, and Andy Miller, the club-like Clan MacFarlane stayed together and, most importantly, played together – in every sense of the word. Ken Eller – affectionately nicknamed “The Captain” by his players – was the glue that held the Clan together through his charisma, charm and outright skill. A lifelong student of pipe bands and piping, he has continued his big presence in the pipe band world as a teacher, judge and popular host and commentator for myriad concerts, recitals and broadcasts. His “Captain’s Corner” website has been a popular resource since the earliest days of the internet. Now 75, but with the his mental agility and charisma as sharp as ever, he enters his final year of eligibility as an RSPBA adjudicator (due to the organization’s age limit rule), and is as in-demand as ever for judging and teaching around the world.

Hal Senyk

The pipe-major of the original rendition of Triumph Street of Vancouver, Hal Senyk helped to form the historically successful band in the early 1970s. Named for an actual street in the British Columbia city, Triumph Street began as a bare-bones ensemble, competing in the highest without matching kilts or even bagcovers, many of the band’s members sporting long beards and mustaches, reflecting the look of the disco ’70s. Triumph Street also shook up the pipe band world by being the first top band to have not just one or two, but several women in its ranks, proving that playing excellence at the top level has nothing to do with gender. As a student of the great Muirhead & Sons Pipe-Major Bob Hardie, and a member of his band for a time, Hal Senyk learned from the master and applied it to Triumph Street’s emphasis on musicality and ensemble. The band, still only a few years old, travelled to Scotland in 1976 and placed fourth at the European Championships and, returning to the UK in 1979, placed fifth and won the drumming at the World Championships in Nottingham, England, helping to change the course of history forever, proving that it was possible to actually get the nod not just for a prize, but for a first prize, from RSPBA judges. Hal Senyk has continued to be a major contributor to piping, teaching numerous bands and individuals, competing here and there with other groups, all while holding down a successful career as a lawyer, which he still enjoys today, from his home in New Westminster, British Columbia.

Jamie Troy

As with Ken Eller and Hal Senyk, Jamie Troy is a true pipe band legend and a towering figure in pipe band history. As the pipe-major of City of Victoria of Victoria, British Columbia, Troy spearheaded the most musically innovative bands of the 1970s. Surrounded by superbly talented and creative pipers like Colin Magee, Bruce Gandy, Steve Geddes, Peter Aumonier, and a crazily-talented Alex Duthart disciple in Lead-Drummer John Fisher, “Victoria” was one of the first bands to harness new music and arrangements from its players. While Troy was clearly the leader, he had the confidence and intelligence to go deeper, producing original music from within. Indeed, two of his pipers, Terry and Jack Lee would go on to huge things, chief among them six World Championship wins, with Simon Fraser University. City of Victoria has the distinction of being known as “the best band not to win the World’s,” when by all accounts – including history-making pipe-majors like Iain McLeod of the Edinburgh City Police – the band deserved to win the title outright in 1979 at Nottingham where they were finished sixth. Retiring from the pipe-majorship in the 1980s, Troy has been a sought-after teacher and judge and, after he acquired in the early 1990s the noteworthy McAllister Reedmakers (created by fellow pipe band legends John K. and Tom McAllister, he and his son, James P. Troy – an extraordinary piping and snare drumming talent) has been creating some of the world’s best pipe chanter reeds at Troy Reedmakers.

Stay tuned to pipes|drums for the third and final part of our exclusive conversation with Ken Eller, Hal Senyk and Jamie Troy.



Triumph Street at the 1979 World’s
June 24, 2019

World’s 1979 summary sheets
July 25, 2019

Triumphant and Victorious – 1979 a historic World’s, 40 years later
July 24, 2019

Willie McErlean, 1931-2014





Forgotten Password?